HEDIS vs. CAHPS: 5 Things Every Patient Should Know About How Healthcare Is Measured
HEDIS vs CAHPS may sound like medical jargon, but chances are you’ve already been part of them without realizing it. Imagine this: you check your mailbox and find a survey from your health plan, asking about your last doctor’s visit. Maybe it was months ago, and you wonder, why are they asking me this now? The truth is, these surveys and scorecards are two of the most important ways the healthcare system measures quality. One looks at the care you actually received. The other asks how you felt about it. Together, they don’t just rate doctors and insurance plans—they shape the healthcare you experience every day.
HEDIS Tracks What Care You Received
The Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) focuses on the clinical side of care. It answers the question: Did you get the care you were supposed to get? Health plans use HEDIS to measure things like whether patients received preventive screenings, appropriate follow-up care, or treatment for chronic conditions. The data comes from insurance claims, electronic health records, and medical charts—not from patients directly.
In short, HEDIS looks at the delivery of recommended care, not the patient’s personal experience of it.
Think of HEDIS as a scorecard that health insurance companies and regulators use to check whether doctors and health plans are doing their jobs. Unlike the surveys you might get in the mail, HEDIS isn’t given to patients at all—it’s filled out with data pulled from medical charts, insurance claims, and electronic health records.
For example, HEDIS tracks whether people with diabetes had their blood sugar checked, if children got their recommended vaccines, or if adults were screened for cancer on time. It’s not asking if you liked your doctor—it’s asking whether the right care happened.
In plain terms: HEDIS is about measuring the “to-do list” of healthcare. Did the provider check the right boxes? Did the health plan make sure the care was delivered? Patients never touch the HEDIS form, but the results still affect them—because the scores determine how plans and doctors are rated.
CAHPS Captures How You Experienced Care
By contrast, the Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS) survey is all about your perspective. Developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), CAHPS asks you directly about your interactions with doctors, staff, and your health plan. Did you feel listened to? Could you get an appointment without long delays? Was it easy to get the care you needed?
CAHPS is the patient voice in healthcare measurement, and your responses help health plans understand what care feels like from the patient side.
Why Both Matter for You
You might be thinking: why does this matter to me as a patient? The answer is that HEDIS and CAHPS are not just academic measures. They feed directly into programs like CMS Star Ratings, which determine how insurance plans are scored. Those scores affect which plans are offered, how much funding they receive, and what improvements they must make.
That means your voice through CAHPS—and the data collected through HEDIS—can influence which health plans thrive and what options are available to you.
Key Differences Between HEDIS and CAHPS
| Aspect | HEDIS | CAHPS |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Clinical effectiveness | Patient experience |
| Data Source | Claims, EHR, medical records | Patient surveys |
| Measures | Preventive care, chronic disease management, utilization | Communication, access, satisfaction |
| Primary Audience | Regulators, insurers, providers | Patients, regulators, insurers |
| Core Question | Did the care happen? | How was the care experienced? |
Timing Can Make Surveys Tricky
Here’s something most patients don’t realize: CAHPS surveys are usually sent out months after your care experience—sometimes two, three, or even six months later. By then, it can be hard to remember exactly how your last appointment went. That delay is intentional, so surveys can capture a range of experiences, but it can also make accurate recall difficult.
This is where patients can take control: keep a few notes after your appointments. Jot down whether your provider explained things clearly, if you felt respected, and how easy it was to get the care you needed. When the survey arrives, you’ll have a record to help you answer confidently and accurately.
How to Fill Out a CAHPS Survey Thoughtfully
Because these surveys come later, it’s easy to let outside frustrations—like billing issues or long hold times with an insurance company—spill into your answers. But CAHPS is designed to measure your experience with providers and health plans directly, not the entire healthcare system’s obstacles.
Here are a few questions to guide you when filling it out:
- Did my provider listen carefully and explain my care clearly?
- Was I able to get the care I needed without unnecessary delays?
- Did the office staff treat me with respect and support me?
- Did my health plan help me access care, or did it create barriers?
- Looking back, do I feel confident in the care I received?
Answering with this focus ensures your survey reflects what it was meant to capture: your actual healthcare experience.
Final Thoughts
HEDIS vs CAHPS is not about one being better than the other—they work together. HEDIS shows whether recommended care was provided. CAHPS shows how that care was experienced by patients. Together, they create a balanced view of healthcare quality.
So the next time a survey arrives in your mailbox, remember: your responses don’t just vanish into a filing cabinet. They help shape how healthcare is delivered and improved—not just for you, but for millions of patients nationwide.
Do you want to discuss your score?
Disclaimer: This education was brought to you today by The Patient Better Project Inc., a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to reshaping the way patients and caregivers navigate care. We are committed to empowering individuals with the knowledge and tools necessary to take control of their health journeys, ensuring that everyone can access the care they need with confidence and clarity.
The information provided here is for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended as, nor should it be considered a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. If you think you may have a medical emergency, immediately call 911 or your local emergency number.